The Car Talk theorem of customer service

Some years ago I heard Tom and Ray Magliozzi–the humorous polymaths who host Car Talk on NPR–clue in an exasperated caller to their theory of customer service: Half the companies out there are like Honda – so rarely do they encounter a problem that when they do, the startled dealer is woefully unprepared to handle customer frustration. Meanwhile, the rest of the companies are like “Brand X” (a then-notorious domestic car company, subsequently much improved) and have so many problems that they’re overwhelmed and don’t know how to handle them either.

Now, this isn’t a post about the venerable Honda marque, or about the automotive industry in general.  What it’s about is this:  All around us, you’ll find that this Car Talk theorem does define a lot of companies, with high applicability outside the automotive industry. On the one hand are technologically near-perfect companies like Google that are utterly ill-equipped to interact with you when things do go awry; on the other hand are totally overwhelmed companies that have no time to talk civilly to you because they’re too busy keeping their heads above the complaint-water.

Which is unfortunate, because neither scenario is sufficient.   That’s why the great, rare, truly customer-focused companies go in two directions, more or less simultaneously, in their efforts to build customer loyalty:

1. Work to eliminate defects, often by benchmarking companies outside of their immediate industry: this is especially important if you are in a service industry, because the experts on eliminating defects are very often in manufacturing rather than service. (Striking example: Horst Schulze’s Ritz-Carlton undertook a lengthy, even grueling effort to benchmark manufacturing companies like Xerox and Motorola, ultimately resulting in the luxury hotel chain winning two Malcolm Baldrige awards–an unprecedented honor for a service company).

2. Work explicitly on how to handle the touchpoints that occur when there are, as there inevitably will be, defects:  in product, service, or – as is common – perception.

One without the other—smiles without systems, or systems without smiles – is a recipe for customer (and bottom-line) disappointment.

By Micah Solomon – keynote speaker, customer service speaker, customer service consultant, and #1 bestselling author of “Exceptional Service, Exceptional Profit: The Secrets of Building a Five-Star Customer Service Organization.” Visit with Micah at Or, click here for your own free chapter  of Micah Solomon’s #1 customer service bestseller, Exceptional Service, Exceptional Profit: The Secrets of Building a Five-Star Customer Service Organization (American Management Association/ AMACOM)


2 thoughts on “The Car Talk theorem of customer service”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *




PLUS Learn the secrets of building the

Worlds Best Customer Service Culture


Thank you! You will hear from us right away.


This site uses cookies to enhance the user experience. By using the site you are agreeing to our privacy policy.